Monday, October 31, 2011

Best of Today: Honesty Isn't Really the Best Policy

It's the phrase you have heard too many times to count: "Honesty is the best policy."

Although this phrase often does teach good morals and help children to stay out of sticky situations, Shakespeare has shown me through "Romeo and Juliet" and "King Lear" that honesty is not the best way to get what you want in many situations. Being honest is supposed to be what will make you happiest and what is smartest. However, Shakespeare has a different perspective.

This idea was proven to be true today, we read about King Lear and his three daughters who in order to inherit their father's land, had to pledge their love for them. Lear's oldest two daughters claimed to love their father in such a way that it was similar to a wife's love for her husband. The oldest sisters were blatently lying to their father in order to please him and inherit as much as possible.

However, when Lear's youngest daughter Cordelia was to pledge her love to her father, her response was that she loved the King in the way that a daughter should love her father and no more or less. This was the honest answer, both for Cordelia and her older sisters. However, Cordelia was the only sister that really tod the truth.

 Because of this, Lear disowns Cordelia and she does not inherit anything. On the other hand, Cordelia's sisters, who lied to their father to please him recieved the land that they wanted. In this way, Shakespeare teaches his readers (or watchers) that being honest is not the way to get what you want.

For example, in Shakespeare's famous play "Romeo and Juliet," Romeo sneaks out and goes to visit Juliet, when he is supposed to be at home. In addition, Romeo and Juliet do not tell their parents of their love for each other because they do not want to make their parents mad. They are dishonest. But by being dishonest, they are able to keep their families happy, at least for a while.

Through my experiences with reading and seeing Shakespeare's plays, I have learned that he does not support the idea that "honesty is the best policy." Instead, Shakespeare gives the notion that the smartest way to deal with a situation is to be a people pleaser, even if it is not entirely or at all true. Thus, this fresh perspective is the Best of Today.

1 comment:

  1. It seems to me, that Shakespeare does indeed sponsor the opposite of "Honesty is the best policy". In various of his works, and multiple times, he makes the characters that lie, cheat, and deceive the most prosperous and well-off. However, in general, I agree with the saying "honesty is the best policy". I have been taught all my life that the best way to live your life and be a moral person is by being truthful. Not only does it gain respect from other people, but it allows for the daily living of a clean conscience. Overall, the idea that Shakespeare presents is truly that opposite from "honestly is the best policy". However, it does not mean that's the best way to live.

    ReplyDelete