Friday, May 11, 2012

Blogging Around

First, I read Katy's blog post about her thoughts on the mash-up and how she learned to accept logical love as a form of true love because of the mash-up.

Here is the comment I posted on her blog:

Katy, I thoroughly enjoyed reading your blog and your thoughts on the Jane Eyre Mash-up. It is amazing to me how almost everyone in our class came into the project thinking that this was just going to be another tedious, time consuming progect that we had to do. However, for many, it turned out to be the most thought provoking and learning facilitative project that we have done ever. Honestly, when I first saw Mr. Allen's mash-up example and how well everything flowed together, I didn't understand how this was possible. I thought that I would never be able to achieve this fluidity in my own mash-up. However, the mash-up, as it did for so many others proved me wrong. It was mind-blowing to see all of my evidence come together as if it was meant to be. I could not believe how everything I had found magically all related in a perfect stream of consciousness. The mash-up proved my previous assertions completely wrong and brought me to the conclusion that you can never reject something that you do not fully understand. Thanks, Katy.

 Next, I read a blog post by Sydney where she made a dialectic between reality and imagination. She learned from The Matrix that reality and imagination may acually be one merged idea. Watching The Matrix completely changed her belief that reality and imagination should be kept seperate and that imagination was not to be applied to real, everyday life.

Here is my comment on her blog:

      Sydney, I really enjoyed reading your blog post about reality and imagination. The topic is so thought provoking that it is mind boggling to think of all of the possibilities that Morpheus' statement about nothing in our lives being real brings to the table. I mean, what if all of our perceptions of the world are only imagined and what if I am currently sitting in a pod of pink goo being fed the information that I am typing a blog comment? This all begs the question: What is reality?
      However, there is no possible way that we can reach a conclusion to this question. Maybe nothing is real. Maybe everything is real.
     And even if everything that we experience is real, we still see it through a lens. I was amazed by Mr. Allen's Disney Animal Kingdom analogy. It is true that no matter where we go, we see the so called real world through a lens. We never see everything for what it truly is, but only a distorted image of reality presented by others. There is no avoiding a fragmented view of the world, no matter how hard we try.
     Therefore, we can never experience a truly real world, even if we do experience reality in the first place.
      Thanks for you post.

Sunday, May 6, 2012

Dialectics: Knowledge and Confinement

While watching The Matrix in class, I was astounded by the way that the movie presents the relationship between knowledge being confined. Throughout my life, I have heard many times that 'knowledge is power' and that 'the truth will set you free,' which in The Matrix, were presented in a literal sense, but when looking deeper into the lives of those who escaped the system of the Matrix were not true. Looking deeper, I saw that in The Matrix the relationship of knowledge of the truth to captivity is very prevalent.

Although not all of the characters that were no longer in the Matrix felt the captivity that knowledge of the truth brought them, the idea that knowing the truth causes captivity is prevalently shown in the character of Cypher. Although he must have at one time, strongly believed that the truth would set him free because of the fact that he did take the red pill, we see that after the nine years that he spent on the Nebuchadnezzar, he wishes that he never took the red pill and that he was still sitting in his pod of pink goo completely oblivious to the truth of the world he lived in. But it was too late.

Cypher's knowledge of the truth trapped him in the real world. There was no good food, no comfortable beds, and no feeling of safety. Eventually, Cypher couldn't handle it anymore. He chose that he would rather forget everything and be completely ignorant than live in the Matrix.

Although the others that escaped the Matrix, didn't go to the extreme of being willing to ruin everything for the others, like Cypher was, in order to forget all of their knowledge, they were also confined because of the knowledge that they possessed. They too, could no longer enjoy the pleasures that were part of living in the Matrix. All of the memories that they had while they were in the Matrix were now just something that they had been programmed to feel. When they drive by the old restaurant that Neo used to go to with friends, he remembers the good times he had there, only to be reminded that they never really existed.

Unlike Cypher, the others that took the red pill do not regret it. However, this does not mean that their knowledge of the truth still does not confine them. They also are taken captive by their knowledge. In the Matrix, if they didn't like their job they could just find a new one. However, now that they are out of the system, the rest of their lives (if they can manage to stay alive) are to be spent keeping the Matrix from fully taking over and eating cold, brown goop.

Even though those who have escaped from the Matrix are able to live a life that is real and a life that is true, they are confined by the their knowledge of the truth. Their only freedom is freedom from the Matrix, otherwise, they are not free at all. The Matrix challenges the idea that 'the truth will set you free' by showing that whose who have a knowledge of the truth are trapped. There is no going back for them.